Antifreeze - Ethylene Glycol vs. Propylene Glycol
Comparing ethylene glycol and propylene glycol antifreeze properties.
Characteristics of ethylene glycol and propylene glycol as antifreeze:
| Property | Ethylene Glycol | Propylene Glycol | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freeze point depression | more effective | less effective | More antifreeze is needed of propylene glycol to achieve the same freeze point |
| Heat transfer efficiency/capability | better | less | Ethylene glycol has superior heat transfer efficiency due to lower viscosity - but more fluid must be circulated to transfer the same amount of energy since Propylene glycol has higher specific heat. |
| Viscosity | lower | higher | Propylene glycol increases major head loss in the systems. Pumps head increased. |
| Flammability | low | low | |
| Chemical oxygen demand | low | higher | |
| Biodegrading | degrades in 10 - 30 days | needs more than 20 - 30 days to degrade | |
| Carcinogenic | no | no | A carcinogen is any substance or agent that promotes cancer |
| Toxic | High level of acute when taken orally, targets the kidneys | Lower level of acute | Ethylene glycol should never be used in any drinking water or food processing system |
| Skin irritant | low | low | Propylene glycol is used in small amounts in cosmetics |
- more about ethylene glycol
- more about propylene glycol
Related Topics
-
Air Conditioning Systems
Design of Air Conditioning systems - heating, cooling and dehumidification of indoor air for thermal comfort. -
Material Properties
Properties of gases, fluids and solids. Densities, specific heats, viscosities and more.
Related Documents
-
Antifreeze - Ethylene Glycol Volume vs. Temperature Rating
Freeze protecting of cooling systems - temperature rating vs. required amount of antifreeze. -
Ethylene - Density and Specific Weight vs. Temperature and Pressure
Online calculator, figures and tables showing density and specific weight of ethylene, C2H4, at varying temperature and pressure - Imperial and SI Units. -
Ethylene Gas - Specific Heat vs. Temperature
Specific heat of Ethylene Gas - C2H4 - temperatures ranging 175 - 900 K. -
Ethylene Glycol Heat-Transfer Fluid Properties
Properties like freezing point, viscosity, specific gravity and specific heat of ethylene glycol based heat-transfer fluids, or brines. -
Freeze Protection of Water based Heat Transfer Fluids
Comparing antifreezes used in water based heat transfer fluids or brines. -
Propylene Glycol based Heat-Transfer Fluids
Freezing points of propylene glycol based heat-transfer fluids suitable for the food processing industry. -
Secondary Coolants - Properties
Comparing properties like specific gravity, freezing points and viscosity for secondary coolants like calcium chloride, sodium chloride, ethylene glycol and propylene glycol.
